After
reading Twain’s selected readings I feel like I gained a good amount of
perspective on the man’s sense of humor.
Two stories in particular struck as something only a very intelligent comedian
would do: Letters From Earth, and The War Prayer.
While
Letters I found to be very funny by playing with expectations and turning
preconceived notions on their head, War Prayer is in its construction one big
joke. A joke essentially is a
setup, and a punch line. The set
up was a church in the midst of a rousing, patriotic prayer from the preacher
is then deflated by the observations of an aged stranger. The stranger posits that, in a
nutshell, praying for victory is praying for failure for somebody else. The punch line is in fact the last line
of the story: “It was believed afterward that the man was a lunatic, because
there was no sense in what he said.”
I found it to be paralleling the same kind of thought process as George
Carlin. He drops a new idea on
you, and then to break the tension pops in a punch line that makes the whole
thing hilarious. But while it
makes you laugh, you feel like you are learning something important as
well. As well as juggling with such
taboo topics as religion and war also put him in familiar territory with
Carlin.
Or am I misinterpreting his
sincerity with sarcasm? Is his
tone more dreadful and serious?
Chris, I think you're right about the connection with Carlin, another person who used comedy for a serious purpose and social criticism. "The War Prayer" is a joke, but in a savage vein.
ReplyDeleteI think that you're right in your interpretation of the speaker's attitude, however, I'm not sure if it's a question of sincerity or sarcasm. I believe that he sought to open the reader's mind and somehow confuse him/her. The section starts out innocent and patriotic enough until BOOM! he throws in a "lunatic" that completely contradicts everything that had already been going on; great character play on his part. Also, dreadful is certainly the right word but serious, I'm not so sure.
Delete-Stevie Morrow
I think you are right on with your interpretation. There is certainly a serious connotation throughout the piece and it gives an important lessons about the realities of war, but Twain deflates the tension by the irony of the onlookers believing the stranger is the lunatic.
ReplyDelete